| 2014 | Bowling Green | 33 | South Alabama | 28 |
| 2015 | Appalachian State | 31 | Ohio | 29 |
| 2016 | Appalachian State | 31 | Toledo | 28 |
| 2017 | Middle Tennessee | 35 | Arkansas State | 30 |
| 2018 | Georgia Southern | 23 | Eastern Michigan | 21 |
| 2019 | Arkansas State | 34 | Florida International | 26 |
| 2020 | Buffalo | 17 | Marshall | 10 |
| 2021 | Georgia State | 51 | Ball State | 20 |
| 2022 | Buffalo | 23 | Georgia Southern | 21 |
| 2023 | Northern Illinois | 21 | Arkansas State | 19 |
| - | Florida Internationally | 000 | Florida Internationally | 000 |