1999	TCU	28	East Carolina	14
2000	Southern Miss	28	TCU	21
2001	Marshall	64	East Carolina	61
2002	Marshall	38	Louisville	15
2003	Miami (Ohio)	49	Louisville	28
2004	Bowling Green	52	Memphis	31
2005	Toledo	45	UTEP	13
2006	Southern Miss	28	Ohio	7
2007	Tulsa	63	Bowling Green	7
2008	Tulsa	45	Ball State	13
2009	Central Michigan	44	Troy	41
2010	Miami (Ohio)	35	Middle Tennessee	21
2011	Northern Illinois	38	Arkansas State	20
2012	Arkansas State	17	Kent State	13
2013	Arkansas State	23	Ball State	20
2014	Toledo	63	Arkansas State	44
2015	Georgia Southern	58	Bowling Green	27
2016	Troy	28	Ohio	23
2017	Appalachian State	34	Toledo	0
2018	Troy	42	Buffalo	32
2019	Louisiana-Lafayette	27	Miami (Ohio)	17
2020	Georgia State	39	Western Kentucky	21
2021	Liberty	56	Eastern Michigan	20
2022	Southern Miss	38	Rice	24
2023	South Alabama	59	Eastern Michigan	10
2024	Arkansas State	38	Bowling Green	31
-	Florida Internationally	000	Florida Internationally	000